Expert Answer Forum
Pope Pius XII QUESTION from M. Sponer April 8, 2000 Dear Mrs Fortin, I would like to study more about Pope Pius XII and the Jews in the time Hitler was in power. Can you recommend some good books that cover these subjects? Would like to study a catholic source and Jewish sources. Thank You.
ANSWER by Mrs. Suzanne Fortin, B.A. on April 11, 2000 Dear Mr. Sponer,
The book I would most recommend for the study of Pius XII and the Jews is Anthony Rhodesâ€™ The Vatican in the Age of Dictators. I donâ€™t know whether Rhodes is a Catholic or not, but he is very sympathetic to the Catholic point of view. Iâ€™ve also heard good things about Sister Margherita Marchioneâ€™s Pius XII: Architect for Peace and Pierre Bletâ€™s Pius XII and the Second World War : According to the Archives of the Vatican.
As for Jewish sources, I canâ€™t say that Iâ€™ve read any. However, I do know that Pinchas E. Lapideâ€™s book, (I think itâ€™s called Three Popes and the Jews) is very supportive of the Catholic viewpoint. He concludes that over 800 000 Jews were saved due to the popeâ€™s effort. As for a book which criticizes the pope, Iâ€™ve heard that Saul Freilanderâ€™s Pius XII and the Third Reich does not have good things to say. I base that on footnotes and citations in other books Iâ€™ve read.
One good place to look for books on any topic is Amazon.com. Readers can post reviews of books theyâ€™ve read. If a book is popular enough, it usually gets a fair number of reviews, and you can tell, from the tone of the reviews whether the book is supportive of the Catholic vision or not. These reviews donâ€™t necessarily reflect the quality of the research or the writing, which may be deficient in spite of good intentions. Nevertheless, itâ€™s a good pointer.
Thanks for your question.
God Bless, Suzanne
Back to Index Page